Sign in

PAN INSIGHTAnalysis

Consumer sentiment in Europe slightly better, but industry still under pressure

Consumer confidence in the eurozone rose in November from minus 17.9 to minus 16.9 points, but this does not create sustainable demand due to rising energy prices and weak industry.

Published
Author
Дмитрий Благодарский
Woman looking at a plant growing from a cracked shell, in the background industrial factory chimneys with smoke and a downward graph.

Buyer sentiment in the eurozone showed slight improvement, and some are trying to see the start of a recovery in this. However, the negative value of the index itself does not create sustainable demand. The region's economy is squeezed between rising energy prices, expensive credit and the task of upgrading production capacity.

Preliminary European Commission data for November recorded a rise in consumer confidence in the eurozone from minus 17.9 to minus 16.9 points. For the EU as a whole the figure was minus 16.5. Reuters also reported that eurozone inflation in October was 4.0%, and in energy 20.8%.

The expectations indicator does not match actual spending

Surveys reflect forecasts, not amounts on receipts. Families may worry less about the future but still cut purchases of expensive goods if real incomes lag behind energy and food prices. Therefore, improvement in sentiment needs to be compared with the dynamics of retail sales in real terms, the volume of consumer credit and changes in savings. Without such data, early optimism risks proving premature.

Energy again determines the pace of inflation in Europe

High gas and electricity tariffs simultaneously act as a tax on buyers and additional costs for companies. When a firm passes on rising costs into prices, inflation spreads to other goods. If it does not, profits fall. When output is cut, there is a threat to jobs. The ECB faces no ordinary excess of demand: raising the rate does not increase gas stocks or speed up construction of power lines.

Industry needs affordable and stable energy resources

Chemical plants, steel mills, glassworks and fertilizer producers are especially dependent on energy costs. The problem, however, is broader: unstable tariffs hinder long-term investment and the choice of site for new production. Even with a decline in current quotations, an investor needs a predictable energy price for several years ahead. In this context, infrastructure, storage and grid modernization affect competitiveness more than statements about industrial revival.

The ECB's task

The central bank must contain secondary inflationary effects without suppressing already weak activity. An overly soft approach may entrench inflationary expectations; an overly tight one will worsen borrowing conditions for industry and budgets. Investors should track wage dynamics, services inflation and long-term expectations, not only the monthly price index.

Implications for markets

European retail benefits from the recovery of real incomes but remains sensitive to rising rates and logistics costs. Banks may receive support from interest margins but risk facing deterioration in credit quality. Utilities with regulated tariffs have a different risk profile compared with energy-intensive producers. In the currency market, the EUR/USD rate will depend on the interest-rate differential and growth rates in the US and Europe. In equities, a single conclusion cannot be applied to the entire STOXX 600.

Possible scenarios

Base horizon 3–6 months: sentiment improves slowly, yet inflation restrains real consumption; cancellation on sharp acceleration of retail sales. Positive horizon 6–12 months: energy shock weakens, real incomes grow, industrial PMI turns around; cancellation on new rise in gas prices. Negative horizon 1–9 months: inflation remains high, ECB tightens policy, corporate profits fall; cancellation on sustained decline in core inflation and growth in orders.

Conclusion

The November confidence index gives reason to stop expecting continuous deterioration. This, however, is not yet reason to speak of an industrial revival. Investors are more interested in finding firms with pricing power, flexible cost structures and access to long-term financing. Europe can regain competitiveness, but a mere change in sentiment will not achieve this.

Methodology for testing the investment idea

A separate risk is linked to correlations. In calm periods different asset classes may move independently, but when liquidity is scarce investors sell what can be sold quickly. As a result, equities, commodities and cryptocurrencies fall simultaneously. This does not prove the identity of the fundamental properties of assets. It shows that short-term pricing depends on the balance sheets of intermediaries and collateral requirements. Therefore, risk assessment must include stress scenarios and not rely solely on average historical correlations.

An investment conclusion must be built on the distinction between an observed fact and the assumption of its continuation. Even an accurate macroeconomic figure does not contain a ready recommendation to buy or sell an asset: the price may already incorporate a significant part of expectations. Therefore, it is necessary to compare the news with the consensus, previous dynamics and market participants' positioning. It is also important to check whether the change is a temporary calendar, seasonality or inventory effect or a real shift in demand. Strong analysis begins not with a confident forecast but with the formulation of conditions under which the forecast will cease to work.

Data sources

Material prepared by expert of the analytical department tradepas.com Dmitry Blagodarsky